Barry Town faced Haverfordwest County in a dramatic penalty shootout on April 26, 2026, after a hard-fought match that ended 1-1. The game took place at Barry's home ground, where the club initially took the lead just three minutes in. Ieuan Owen's quick thinking allowed Ollie Hulbert to score from the edge of the box, giving Barry Town a promising start. Despite several opportunities to extend their lead, including a potential penalty shout that went unheeded by the referee, the club could not capitalize on their early advantage.

In the second half, Haverfordwest equalized through Greg Walters, who finished off a well-executed team move. With the score tied at 1-1 after 90 minutes, the match proceeded to penalties. Unfortunately for Barry Town, the shootout proved disastrous. Keenan Patten's opening penalty was saved, and both Ben Margetson and Callum Sainty failed to convert their attempts, hitting the crossbar and the woodwork, respectively.

Haverfordwest County emerged victorious, winning the penalty shootout 3-1, and secured their place in the Cymru Premier European play-off final against Penybont. This defeat marks a disappointing end to Barry Town's hopes of European qualification this season, despite their strong performance throughout the match.